Halifax Regional Municipality v. Northern Construction Enterprises Inc., 2016 CanLII 7603 (SCC)

This application for leave to appeal was considered by the Supreme Court of Canada.

Northern Construction Enterprises Inc. (“Northern”) applied for a permit to develop an aggregate quarry in the Halifax Regional Municipality (“HRM”). When the HRM chose not to award the permit, Northern appealed to the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (“UARB”), arguing that the HRM had no jurisdiction to deny the permit because the Province of Nova Scotia, not individual municipalities, has the authority to determine the location of quarries. The HRM had enacted a by-law prohibiting all but the most basic quarrying activities, and it argued that it had the authority to do because although the Province had jurisdiction over quarries, the HRM had jurisdiction over “developments adjacent to…quarries.” Northern asked the UARB to declare that the HRM had no authority to enact that by-law, and it argued that the HRM’s decision to deny the permit should be overturned.

The UARB found that it had no jurisdiction to determine whether the HRM had the authority to enact the by-law at issue, and it upheld the HRM’s interpretation of the by-law. Northern appealed to the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia, which considered whether the HRM had the authority to enact the by-law itself. The Court held that the by-law was valid, and it affirmed the HRM’s interpretation of the by-law as well.

Northern then appealed to the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal, which considered the two matters separately. Although the Court held that the by-law was not valid, it affirmed that the HRM’s interpretation of the by-law fell within the acceptable range of outcomes. Since the by-law itself was declared invalid, the Court’s decision on this point was moot.

When the HRM sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada, leave to appeal was denied.

To read other decisions related to this case, go to:

Northern Construction Enterprises Inc. v. Halifax (Regional Municipality), 2014 NSSC 166 (CanLII)

Northern Construction Enterprises Inc. v. Halifax (Regional Municipality), 2014 NSCA 88 (CanLII)

Northern Construction Enterprises Inc. v. Halifax (Regional Municipality), 2015 NSCA 44 (CanLII)

Northern Construction Enterprises Inc. v. Halifax (Regional Municipality), 2015 NSCA 43 (CanLII)

View the Decision on CanLII:
https://www.canlii.org/en/ca/scc-l/doc/2016/2016canlii7603/2016canlii7603.html?resultIndex=5

Disclaimer:
Case briefs in our Resource Library are drafted by law students who work or volunteer with East Coast Environmental Law, and East Coast Environmental Law does not guarantee their fullness or accuracy. Library users should not rely on case briefs as comprehensive accounts of the issues, facts, reasoning, or outcomes at stake in any given case. 

If you require more detailed information about a court decision or legal issue, please consider using our Environmental Law Inquiry Service to request information from our staff.